Industries
Data centre acoustics and noise assessment
Few building types have moved from obscure to contentious as quickly as the data centre. As facilities have grown and moved closer to residential communities, noise has become one of the main issues raised in approvals, in council chambers, and by the neighbours afterward.
It is a hard problem and deserves to be treated as one. A large facility runs a great deal of plant continuously, including overnight, and the acoustic outcome depends on decisions made early: where equipment sits, what gets selected, how the site is laid out.
What comes up most
Where the plant goes.
Equipment placement is usually settled by electrical routing, structural constraints and site efficiency. It is also the single biggest lever on the sound reaching a receptor, and the easiest one to move while the site plan is still open.
Selection versus mitigation.
Fan and chiller selections are made against capacity, redundancy and cost. Once locked, the remaining options are enclosures, barriers and silencers, all of which perform less well than a different selection made earlier.
Low-frequency content.
Large fans and cooling plant produce a great deal of low-frequency sound. It travels further, passes through envelopes more readily, and a single A-weighted number does not represent it, so a facility can sit within its limit and still be audible indoors at a distance.
Generator testing.
Routine testing runs on a schedule that does not always align with the assumptions in an approval. Worth settling how testing will be treated at the assessment stage rather than after the first test.
Phased buildout.
Facilities are frequently approved in phases and built over years. An assessment based on phase one has to anticipate the fully built condition, including plant added under a later approval.
The receptor that arrives later.
Sites chosen for power and land are not always sites that stay industrial. Nearby residential approvals can change the applicable limits during a project’s life.
In front of a community
The assessment gets read out loud.
Council and public meetings ask acoustic questions directly, and reviewers, planners, councillors and residents all read this work. It has to set out plainly what the facility will produce, what has been done about it, and what can still be changed.
The understanding is built during design.
Placement, selection, orientation and layout close in sequence, so knowing which are still open, and what each is worth, is more useful than a list of everything that could theoretically be done.
Define the outcome, then design to it.
A facility of this size will have an acoustic presence, and pretending otherwise helps nobody. The work is to define what a reasonable outcome looks like for the site and the neighbours, then design to it deliberately.
Our engineers’ experience
Bentham’s engineers have worked as acoustical consultants on data centre projects in Canada, the United States and Europe: acoustic assessments supporting approvals, mechanical and equipment noise control, enclosure design for cooling and standby power, and investigation work after a facility is running.
Some of that work:
Approved in phases, over years.
One large data centre in the Greater Toronto Area was approved in phases across half a dozen years, with permitting and noise control design running throughout. Because a single model carried through every phase, each change of generator or cooling selection could be tested in days, and no phase reopened the ones before it.
A complaint, and what it changed.
A large data centre adopted a novel cooling technology and complaints followed once it was running. The investigation found the installed fans did not perform to the sound data in the original documentation. Measuring the equipment as installed identified the sources actually driving the levels, and the remedial measures brought the site back into compliance. It is why manufacturer sound data is treated as something to verify.
Rooftop plant on a dense site.
On a downtown refurbishment in Vancouver, rooftop chillers were overlooked by neighbouring buildings on several sides. Noise control and the airflow the chillers need pull directly against each other, and the enclosure that resolved it was built and holds both.
Bentham Acoustics is new. Its engineers are not. The projects described here were carried out by Bentham engineers over their careers, at this firm and before it.
A full list of relevant project experience is available on request.
Standards and requirements in Ontario
A data centre in Ontario is a stationary noise source, assessed against the sound level limits in MECP publication NPC-300. The applicable limit depends on the acoustical class of the area and on the time of day, with the night-time period generally governing.
Approval route.
Most data centres do not strictly require a provincial approval. Where one applies, or where the formal route is the better option, it is an Environmental Compliance Approval or a registration under the Environmental Activity and Sector Registry, O. Reg. 1/17, with the sound emissions assessed through the Primary or Secondary Noise Screening Method or a full Acoustic Assessment Report.
Municipal and planning.
Noise by-laws apply separately, and site plan and zoning approvals frequently attach their own conditions. Where a facility sits near land planned for residential use, a Class 4 designation can be applied to the proposed development, shifting some mitigation onto it rather than the established facility.